Jimmy's Famous Heros

Jimmy's Famous Heros is a beloved sandwich shop and deli nestled in the heart of Brooklyn’s Sheepshead Bay neighborhood, where quality and tradition come together to create an unforgettable eating experience. With over four decades of history, this local institution has become synonymous with authentic, mouthwatering heroes that speak to the heart of classic New York deli culture.

Step inside Jimmy’s, and you immediately feel welcomed by the warm, down-to-earth vibe that reflects the family-run nature of the business. The aroma of freshly baked Italian bread mingles effortlessly with the scent of premium cold cuts and crisp, garden-fresh vegetables, promising bites full of both comfort and bold flavor.

The menu showcases a variety of irresistible sandwiches crafted with care, inviting you to indulge in signature selections like the Chicken Cutlets Sandwich – a perfectly thin-sliced, fried chicken cutlet nestled between soft bread – and the legendary Roast Beef & Cheese piled generously with rich beef and melty cheese. For those craving classic Italian deli delights, the Mortadella with Provolone, Mayo, Oil & Vinegar, Lettuce & Tomato offers a harmony of creamy and tangy notes that dance on the palate. Don’t miss out on the Half Ham and Swiss or the Roast Beef Hero with “the Works” – both celebrated options among loyal patrons.

Side offerings include homemade desserts like velvety Cannolis and crisp Butter Crunch Cookies, rounding out your meal with a perfectly sweet finish. To complement your sandwich, a carefully selected range of beverages, from the refreshing Orange Snapple to energizing Gatorade, is ready to quench your thirst.

What truly sets Jimmy’s Famous Heros apart is not just the food but the heartfelt dedication behind the counter. As one long-time customer, Michael Heffez, raved, “BEST heroes in the universe! Hands down! Amazing fresh food; all the vegetables and breads and cold cuts are top of the line quality. This place is a true GEM!” Meanwhile, regular patrons like Frank Dee praise the staff’s exemplary service, noting the extra effort to accommodate orders and maintain quality even during busy hours. This attentiveness shines through, making each visit feel like coming home.

Victor, the legendary sandwich maker who has been part of Jimmy's for decades, crafts each hero with precision and love, understanding fully that a great sandwich is an experience, not just a meal. Moses S beautifully summarized this sentiment: “This isn't just a deli; it's an institution, a love letter to the neighborhood.” Whether you’re a local or a visitor, a trip to Jimmy’s Famous Heros transforms a simple sandwich into a celebration of Brooklyn’s rich culinary heritage.

Perfect for a quick takeout lunch or a comforting family dinner, Jimmy’s combos of fresh ingredients, generous portions, and genuine hospitality make it easy to see why so many keep coming back. The blend of traditional Italian deli elements with Brooklyn’s neighborhood soul offers a truly distinct bite that lingers long after the last crumb is gone.

For anyone craving a fresh, satisfying hero sandwich in Sheepshead Bay, Jimmy’s Famous Heros truly lives up to its name—famous for all the right reasons.